Tuesday, 2 September 2008

Safety First

You know it happens to everybody, and I always welcome those moments of epiphany where in spite of thinking I have a reasonable grasp of a subject, I realise that I missed something. I missed something big.
Happened again today.
For some time I have argued the point that the percentage of time that frost fans operate in a year is wrong for this reason or that reason and to be honest it's all about the weather and there's the definition of random.
Well, I believe that I have been blinded by arguing the case placed before me that resource consultants want you to believe that it's XX% of the nights in a year that are affected.
Sure it happens, but that's not the main issue.
The main issue isn't even noise.

The main issue is DEATH.

That's going to happen to someone after a sleepless night of being kept awake by frost fans. It won't matter if its the first night without sleep or the third in a row.
This is how it will go.

Someone will be deprived of sleep overnight due to frost fans operating.
The next day they will get into their car and make a bad decision.
They'll die.

New Zealand has an excellent source of local information on the effects of driving without getting enough sleep at http://www.akilla.co.nz/.

It's pretty simple.
It's the equivalent of drunk driving without the alcohol.
Feel free to google the term "sleep deprivation" and driving. Frankly it's horrifying.
You'll read things like;
The driving data provide confirmation that sleepiness is a significant factor leading to off-road accidents. Accident rates showed a small increase after a moderate reduction in the previous night's sleep (4h vs. 8h), and a marked increase with progressive sleep deprivation.
and
Sleepiness (drowsiness, somnolence, hypersomnia) is a feeling of abnormal drowsiness, often with a tendency to actually fall asleep. It is associated with memory deficit, impaired social and occupational performance, and car crashes
and
In a study published this week in the British journal Occupational and Environmental Medicine, researchers in Australia and New Zealand report that sleep deprivation can have some of the same hazardous effects as being drunk.
Frankly, I feel a little sick.

3 comments:

kiwi said...

I have had this thought as well for some time but with no real proof. We have to cross a railway line each day as do lots of neighbours, who is to blame if they have been kept awake all night by frost fans and they miss the train coming at them that they don't see because of sleep deprivation.

J Frost said...

It would be an interesting correlation to make between traffic accidents and frost fan events. I actually think it could be done relativly easily since you have control data from frosty days with no frost fan action during the winter and then you have data from days when the machines are operating. I wonder who has that data LTSA?

Anonymous said...

Hey. Turns out that there is significant information at the Ministry of Transport and LTSA websites. Including this Crash fact sheet from 2007.
http://www.transport.govt.nz/assets/NewPDFs/Fatigue-Crash-Factsheet-July-07-Web.pdf
There could be something here