Showing posts with label frost protection. Show all posts
Showing posts with label frost protection. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 June 2010

Painless Frost Protection

Just thought it would be a good opportunity to update the blog with information on the progress of the Raytheon sponsored microwave frost protection system Tempwave.
It would appear that they have been running trials in an Ontario vineyard over the Northern Winter.
Follow the links for updated information and new pictures.
http://www.raytheon.com/newsroom/technology/rtn09_tmpwv/index.html
http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2010/06/25/raytheon-turns-swords-into-plowshares/
http://www.winesandvines.com/template.cfm?section=news&content=73695
tmp tempwave tfb Raytheon turns swords into plowshares photo  Tempwave towers

Sunday, 18 October 2009

Bladeless Fans and the Pursuit of Technology

Bladeless fans I hear you say. That doesn't sound right.
Well, the concept is unusual, and if it hadn't come from Sir James Dyson himself, I would be more concerned.


But if you have a look at the product home page here, or the related video where Sir James explains the principles here or (my favorite) a wonderful explanation of how it works here you will see a concept that is strange, but obviously effective.
Now I'm not going to expect that the concept will scale to something suitable for frost protection. However, it is a very real and somewhat related example of engineering applying solutions to problems that are out of the square.
This same development needs to continue for frost fans.
In short, the concept of using an inversion layer to provide warmth to a crop is a good one. Frost fans are an effective means of achieving this end. However, they have side effects.
The Defender has taken a step to reduce those side effects by employing a more aerodynamic blade and making it rotate more slowly and then compensating for the reduced flow by making the blade larger with a higher pitch.
The C49 from Frost Boss has taken a step further by using their already quiet 4 bladed technology and implementing an aerodynamic blade in conjunction with cleverly examining the airflow from the perspective of the actual job that the fan is doing (this is a relatively low speed fan compared to aircraft propellers) and designed their blades to suit. This is what puts them one step ahead of the Defender.
The end result for both these manufacturers is quieter fans that do the same (or perhaps better) job than before. This same evolution needs to continue but with an even bolder change in direction to allow for greater reduction in noise. A bladeless Dyson fan will probably not be the answer, but the answer WILL be something different from a conventional fan. Keep your thinking caps on.

Saturday, 10 October 2009

Ahh... helicopters at night are a vineyard's delight

Sadly, they're not quite as exciting if you're trying to sleep.
Hovering helicopters fall in the 'too hard' basket in terms of regulation for noise.
The CAA are only concerned with aircraft safety and the RMA specifically precludes aircraft in flight.
There's options there for exploring, but as yet there's no organisation with enough moxie to try and prevent them doing whatever they want to do. And frankly they're a better option than frost fans in many ways. They don't get used unless they're REALLY needed. As opposed to frost fans which will be switched on just because they can be in some cases.

Anyway, there's plenty flying about this evening, so I suppose it's time for another frost, By my count this will be the 5th night this season that I've heard them running, and I believe that others have had it much worse (a quick check of the letters to the editor will confirm that).

While I'm here I note that MetVUW has painted a not so pretty picture for the next few days. Could this be four nights in a row coming up?
Update: This prediction was correct (the fans ran). Although it seemed a bit warm to me!
This prediction was incorrect: No frost on Monday morning. That's nice
Update: this prediction was correct. Frost on Sunday Morning.


Friday, 4 September 2009

There's a new Boss in town. Frost Boss

Yes indeedy, a couple of the new C49 four bladed Frost Boss fans have apparently touched down in the Waihopai valley.
To my knowledge this would be the first sighting in the wild and how about the timing? A few nights of frost coming up (although it may be a bit early for most vines).
Some will have noticed only a couple of fans running last night.
So will these be noticeably quieter? They certainly look the part. Time will tell if they sound the part.

Saturday, 11 July 2009

Frost Fans are equal opportunity annoyers

The good folks in Surrey, British Columbia are finding out that frost fans are more than willing to wake up residents who live next to blueberries as well as vineyards.
(See this article in the Peace Arch News)
This should serve to emphasise that the problem isn't the fan's, so much as the arrogance of those who install them in situations where the health of their neighbours are of little concern.
Another lesson to be reinforced is the lack of fortitude of local government in the face of health of residents on one hand and making money on the other.

Tuesday, 24 March 2009

Why do Wind Machines Operate in Autumn?

Well, first of all there was a limited number of frost machines active last night. not really too cold and I certainly saw no evidence of frost on the ground.

However, this leads to the question of why the frost fans will even start up in Autumn?

We know that Spring frosts will damage new growth and hinder development, but it's a different reason to beat the frost in the Autumn.

The grapes are on the vine and are still developing. As such the plant is continuing to provide nutrients and energy to the fruit via the chemical processes associated with photosynthesis (photosynthate). If the leave are damaged by frost they no longer provide nutrients to the grapes and the reverse can occur where the plant can try to draw goodness back from the grapes. This is undesirable and typically it is prudent to pick grapes as soon as practical from a vineyard that has suffered frost damage in the Autumn.
Additionally, there is a risk of the wood of the vine not becoming fully mature before a frost and the resultant injury causing an increased susceptibility to disease.
Just when you thought it couldn't get worse. If frost damages the leaves and they die and this is followed by rain, the machine harvesting of the grapes can be difficult because of the dead leaves clogging the harvesters.

So there you go. Frost protection is useful. Frost protection is good. Just pick the right type and keep the frost fans away from your neighbours!

Monday, 9 March 2009

How ideal are smudge pots for frost protection?

I have deliberately chosen smudge pots (not to be confused with return stack burners) as the first frost protection method to be evaluated as they have some aspects of operation that are controversial (like being so bad that even local body Councils have banned their use).
How do they feature?

The Grower:
  • It should be cost effective to install and run.                                  Very Cost effective
  • It must be reliable.                                                                       The mechanism is simple, so failures are unlikely.
  • It must protect the crop from frost.                                               Effective protection.
  • It should not be labour intensive.                                                  There is a medium to high requirement for attention during operation
  • It must be safe to operate.                                                           Probably about medium
The Crop:
  • It must not affect the normal growth / development of the plant.   No problem
  • It should not introduce any foreign contaminants.                          Probably a low to medium risk here.
  • The quality of the fruit should be unchanged.                                Probably low to medium again
The Environment:
  • It should not deplete a natural resource.                                      It burnt oxygen, but this hasn't been identified yet as a resource depletion issue.
  • It should not make any physical impact other than on the crop.    The physical impact was high with huge palls of smoke covering large areas and soot accompanying it.
  • It should not introduce any pollutant to the environment.             Very high with considerable pollutants released into the atmosphere.
The Neighbour:
  • Its operation mustn’t affect their health.                                   Medium risk with smoke pollution exposure
  • Its operation shouldn’t degrade their property values.                Property values relatively unaffected unless it was during a frost season (so low)
  • It shouldn’t degrade their enjoyment of their own property.        During times of use, enjoyment would drop considerably.
What can we read from this?
Well with features that were important to the grower and relatively benign affect on the crop, the technique was popular in the day. In spite of a significant impact on the environment and neighbours. However as consciousness was raised to the health risks and pollution impact, regulations were enacted to limit, prevent or alter the activity.Parallels can be drawn with frost fans in the sense that what little regulations are in place are not well structured or not followed and this has allowed the wild west mentality to take hold. Now as the impact of the devices has begun to be felt by more and more people, their use is being viewed less favorably.

Sunday, 8 March 2009

What’s the ideal form of frost protection?

There are a number of different individual features to consider and there are a number of separate interest groups with stakes in the method.

Interest groups:

  • The Grower
  • The Crop
  • The Environment
  • The Neighbours

The Grower:
Features that are important to the grower are things like;

  • It should be cost effective to install and run.
  • It must be reliable.
  • It must protect the crop from frost.
  • It should not be labour intensive.
  • It must be safe to operate.

The Crop:
Features that are important to the crop are things like;

  • It must not affect the normal growth / development of the plant.
  • It should not introduce any foreign contaminants.
  • The quality of the fruit should be unchanged.

The Environment:
Features that are important to the environment are things like;

  • It should not deplete a natural resource.
  • It should not make any physical impact other than on the crop.
  • It should not introduce any pollutant to the environment.

The Neighbour:
Features that are important to the neighbour are things like;

  • Its operation mustn’t affect their health.
  • Its operation shouldn’t degrade their property values.
  • It shouldn’t degrade their enjoyment of their own property.

Now I am sure that there are other features and possibly other interest groups in the wider scheme of things, but this is a fair start.
Of course the list provides an opportunity to evaluate different methods on their appropriateness, but because each interest group has a different agenda, there will always be conflicting drivers for what constitutes an ideal method.
That said, there is merit in evaluating the methods and comparing them, simply because it highlights the disparity between the different groups, promotes debate and perhaps arrives at resolutions / compromises.