Showing posts with label monitoring. Show all posts
Showing posts with label monitoring. Show all posts

Thursday, 22 April 2010

Why are consent fees rising?

Yes they went up. Quite a bit according to this article in the Marlborough Express.
So I suppose the Chairman of the New Zealand Winegrowers had good reason to wonder what was going on.
Now I don't know a lot about what makes a Council tick financially. But I do know that in order to properly monitor the rules and regulations of a District plan it will cost a bit of money.
So I suppose you would ask yourself just what are they monitoring and how are the Council maintaining compliance and who are breaking the rules?
Well good questions and good news. Because for a little taste of the evil doings that are going on around the District, the MDC released excerpts from "Environment Action 2008" last year.
Let's have a look....
Prosecution action:
Highfield Terrace Downs Limited for Unauthorised works in a wetland.
Infringement Notices:
Wither Hills Vineyards Marlborough Limited for Discharge of winery wastewater
Foxes Island Wines Limited for Discharge of grapes and wash water to the stormwater system which enters the Co-op Drain.
Spy Valley Wines for Discharge of winery wastewater to land.
Gareth Lynn for Discharge of RDV to wastewater system which enters the Co-op Drain.
Indevin Limited for Discharge of RDV to wastewater system which enters the Co-op Drain.
Robyn Tiller for Discharge to air from burning plastic and treated wood.
Michael Tiller for Discharge to air from burning plastic and treated wood.
Isabel Estate Limited for Discharge to air from burning plastic and treated wood.
Ashmore Vineyards Limited for Discharge of smoke from burning green vegetation.
Lynford Vineyards Limited for Unauthorised filling of a waterway.
Bronwyn Grant for Discharge of smoke from burning plastic vine guards.
Weta Estate Limited for Discharge of smoke to air by burning green vegetation.
Boundary Bay Vineyards Limited for Removal of trees from floodway.
Vines Development Company for Discharge of stormwater from earthworks without sediment traps.
McKean Estates Limited for Disturbing bed of a river.
McKean Estates Limited for Diverting water.
McKean Estates Limited for Tree removal in a riverbed.
McKean Estates Limited for Discharge of sediment from earthworks without sediment traps.
Matakana Estate for Discharge of smoke to air from burning green vegetation.
Weta Estates Limited for Discharge of smoke to air from burning green vegetation.
Saint Claire Estate Wines Limited for Discharge of smoke to air from burning treated timber and plastic.
Odyssey Vineyards Limited for Discharge of smoke to air from burning treated timber and plastic.
Delegats Wine Estate for Discharge of smoke from burning green vegetation.
Abatement Notices:
Alistair Shave for The take and use of water to irrigate a vineyard
Indevin Limited for Discharge of contaminates to a waterway, via the stormwater system.
Wither Hills Vineyards Limited for Discharge of winery wastewater to land in excess of 10mm/day.
Indevin Limited for Discharge of winery wastewater to a waterway via the Council stormwater system.
Indevin Limited for Dumping of grape marc to land.
Richard Campbell for Dumping of grape marc to land
Wairau River Wines Limited for Discharge of winery wastewater to land in excess of 10 mm/day
Anthony Moore for Discharge of grape marc to land
Boundary Bay Vineyards for Removal of trees in floodway
Weta Estates Limited for Burning of unauthorised materials.
Matakana Estate Limited for Unauthorised excavation and vegetation removal in a floodway
Matakana Estate Limited for Burning of unauthorised materials.
M & M Wairau Investments Limited for Taking of water for irrigation of vineyard.
Daniel Watson for Taking of water for irrigation of vineyard
Weta Estates Limited for Taking of water for irrigation of vineyard
Vines Development Company Limited for Taking of water for irrigation of vineyard.
McKean Estate Marlborough Limited for Taking water.

So I suppose the cost of monitoring and enforcing compliance has to cover the efforts of chasing the offenders mentioned above?
So I agree with the New Zealand Winegrowers. The fees have gone up a lot.
But I can sort of see why...

Saturday, 10 April 2010

Frost Fan debate: The age of reason?

I like the idea of the debate page in the Marlborough Express.
So I suppose it would have only been a matter of time before frost fans featured.
Young Malcolm took the 'reason' slant. And why not? It's kind of obvious when you boil the issue down. Frost fan operators should be just as responsible for producing a reasonable of noise as defined in the RMA as any other industry. Why should they be special? Perhaps the Chairman of the New Zealand Winegrowers has a reason? Let's take a look....
There is apparently a significant cost in running a frost machine. Frankly a few hundreds of dollars of diesel is pittance beside the potential earnings of the crop, so let's not mince words here. An operator will ALWAYS err on the side of caution when deciding whether or not to operate his fans. Some operators won't even take as much care as young Stuart. I mean why bother to wake up at 3am when you can simply tell your vineyard manager to turn them on at the first sniff of cool weather and turn them off at sunrise. Small price to pay (especially when you live in another part of the country).
Clearly every time he ran his machines he was faced with no other alternative. This is WAR! (have you noticed how the effort is described as frost fighting? This is genuinely how some growers approach the business of frost protection, no matter what technique is used. And as we know, in war, not everyone's following the Geneva convention (I mean history is written by winners isn't it?)).
I see that "landowners have a responsibility to ensure that the adverse effects of their viticultural practices are mitigated as far as practically possible" So there are adverse effects of viticultural practices, but if you've chosen to grow your crop in an unsuitable area, never fear, you only have to make an effort to mitigate adverse effects, not actually mitigate them.
All the hot air over national standards and complicated rules hides the fact that the New Zealand Winegrowers have not made any practical attempt to limit noise pollution. This includes their code of practice which doesn't even pretend to be enforceable. What Stuart is really saying is let's forget about this petty local squabbling and elevate the issue to a national level so that no affected individual will be inclined to participate and we can either write our own rules or simply drag the process out for longer.
Other Councils are less combative?  How much less combative can they get. For crying out loud, they don't even monitor the noise, just the complaints!!

Thursday, 29 October 2009

The Marlborough District Council: Where the bleeding obvious goes to be ignored

Meet Hans Versteegh. Regulatory manager for the Marlborough District Council.
He is indeed in the hot seat. Frost fans must keep the plate pretty full I suppose.
Well I suppose if you had a rule in your district plan that you couldn't enforce, that would be troublesome wouldn't it?
Actually it would only be troublesome if it caused a nuisance or something. Kind of like if the rule was aimed at keeping a really loud noise quiet.
So if people thought the really loud noise was unreasonable, they could complain and get it sorted right?
Oh, hold on, you can't test the noise. Darn it.
Wait, what if someone demonstrated a way to tell if the noise was to loud?
Ahh.. I see the master at work... Agree with him that the method does show non compliance, but then wring your hands because it might be a bit scary to ask if the operators or the installers would they please set them to a correct level.

Thanks again to the Blenheim Sun Community newspaper for this follow up article to the previous piece on checking compliance.
I see that Hans mentions that prosecuting offenders means dealing with the court and criminal jurisdiction system. I presume that those who run their fans at a non compliant level are actually criminal offenders.
Sorry Hans, would that be the Criminal Court or the Environment Court?
I like your explanation better. If the fans are being too noisy, call the police. Hans said it's the right thing to do. It's a criminal act after all.
Can you get a finding beyond reasonable doubt on an unreasonable noise? (you're not ACTUALLY the legal expert are you?)
P.S. Hans: I see you're the Marlborough contact for the protection and recovery of the pygmy button daisy. Those daisy's really need our help. Really.

Inspector Frost. Nice. Very Nice.

Good on you Malcolm for providing a method for checking if fans are breaching the District plan. The attached scans are from the Blenheim Sun Newspaper, who ran a story on his efforts which he also posted here recently.

Of course there was also a reply from the Council which will follow in a separate post...

Saturday, 24 October 2009

Frost Fan Issue National News

TV1 viewers would have seen an article on the frost fan issue on tonights news broadcast
The text version of the story is here or you can watch the video segment here.
Stuart Smith couldn't help himself and touted the same tired scaremongering.
Likewise wine grower Chris Simmonds claimed that it was just 1% of the frost fans that were causing the problems. Err... Chris, have you checked out the results of the test of frost fan compliance lately? That would be more like 90% of them do not meet the requirements.
Sorry Chris, frost fan users in Marlborough have been running their machines at too high a level for years and as a result they have defecated in their own nest. THAT's why the Council is being forced to impose new regulations. It's the irresponsible users who thought they would set them to any level they wanted because the Council never checks them. It's not a few... It's almost all....
The chickens are coming home to roost.

Monday, 12 October 2009

This is one reason why it's noisy in Marlborough

OK, It's fair to say that there has been some pressure applied to release this information (thanks Jack), but it goes to the heart of explaining one of the reasons why there is a noise problem from frost fans in Marlborough.
In short, Orchard Rite and Amarillo frost fans are being installed and run at speeds that result in noise that exceeds the limits laid down in the District Plan.
This information was a long time in the making and further testing would help represent the scale of the problem, however, in the short amount of testing done to date there is no doubt that two of the three frost fan brands are being installed in contravention of the District Plan.
The document that is here describes the results of the tests and provides the figures to back up the statement.
The data has been offered to the Marlborough District Council for independent checking. However, I encourage anyone to do the testing themselves to confirm the problem. The instructions for doing so are here.

Regards Malcolm

Practical observations on evaluating frost fan noise

Thanks for having me back on the blog again Jack.

This has obviously been a busy time for frost fan users and people concerned with their noise. I had previously posted a description of a method for evaluating the noise from a frost fan by measuring its rotation and a reason that this is necessary. This is a follow up to that description to describe the practical aspects of the measurement system.

The recent frost events (6th,7th,11th of October 2009) provided an opportunity to evaluate the method for testing frost fans for compliance with Council regulations.

The evaluation was very useful in that it highlighted some improvements, limitations and successes of the method. It also threw up an unexpected piece of data that will be relatively important in evaluating the current noise environment and potential improvements.

The testing has confirmed that the measurement of fan rotation at night is possible and practical. It can easily be carried out at a distance of over 200m, depending on the type of fan (the dark green of the typical Amarillo means that the practical recording distance of these machines is reduced).

Recording using infrared is possible at 100m, but unless there is a specialist requirement for it, visible light gives an easier result to work with.

Noting the direction that the fan is facing is important, and often it is easier to note that verbally when recording as a note for later analysis.

The use of GPS to track location is very useful when recording in some remoter areas when familiar geographic references are absent.

It was found that in spite of the success of recording fans at night, it was remarkably easy to record a large number of fans just before and after sunrise as the ‘nightshot’ capabilities of some cameras provide suitable illumination for recording.

As the results of the evaluation have the potential to cause a certain amount of interest from more that one side of the frost fan noise debate, they will be posted separately at the time that the Council is informed of the issue via the complaint process.

Regards Malcolm

Tuesday, 22 September 2009

The MDC shows intestinal fortitude

In the Marlborough express today is a report of the good folks from Mount Riley Vineyards having a bit of a squeal about being found in breach of the noise rules for frost fans.
It would appear that not only is it ridiculously difficult to get any testing done on a frost fan, but when it is carried out and doesn't go the way the winery wants, they want to carry on with business as usual anyway.
Per the suggestion from an earlier commentator, here's some info from Mount Riley Vineyards website.
They own seven vineyards. The offending vineyard in this case appears to be the Waihopai Vineyard. There is a picture of it on their website, but the frost fans do not feature. Pity, since any publicity is good publicity right?
The winery is owned by John and Lyn Buchanan and their daughter Amy. Amy's husband (Matt Murphy is the wine-maker). Possibly one of the reasons that they are keen to explore legal proceedings is that Amy is also a solicitor. Very handy when faced with unreasonable neighbors that seem to go on and on about trifling things like being kept awake at night.
It can be assumed that the quote from their website "At Mt Riley we believe in winemaking by minimal intervention" should be taken in context that minimal intervention can take the form of multiple twirling blades of metal operating throughout the night and keeping our neighbours awake.
If you want to find out more about their wines you should go to this page.
And don't miss an opportunity to read their vintage reports here. True to form for winegrowers, it would appear that every year is special.
Thank you Mount Riley for your compassion in dealing with this matter in a responsible manner. In fact could this be the industry/individual discussions alluded to in the Council meeting on the 24th of August? Or could it be the actions of persons that were described by Councillor Maher at the same meeting?
Irrespective, there is kudos to be handed out to the Marlborough District Council for recognising the situation for what it is. Simply a case of a landowner breaching the rules. Are they special?
The real pity of the entire episode is that even if Mount Riley did the right thing and set their fans to a responsible noise level they would still breach the noise level set by the World Health Organisation for healthy living.

Monday, 21 September 2009

Who's right? Defender Advertising or Defender Testing data?

Further to the information in the Defender testing document, I note that there is an inconsistency in the technical data supplied.
In the University of Canterbury document the nominal engine speed is given as approximately 2000rpm and the fan speed as approximately 360rpm.
In the Defender/FMR advertising the gear drives that are reported for the upper and lower gears are UD105 and W85 respectively.
So here's the deal. The ratios specified for the gears on the Amarillo web page are 1.64:1 for the UD105 and 2.25:1 for the W85.
And so in theory 2000/(1.64x2.25) should equal 360 if both the UoC and FMR Advertising were talking about the same product.
But it doesn't.
FMR are either still peddling the same specifications for the Amarillo in the Defender advertising or the University of Canterbury are having problems with an equation that a 9 year old could get right. I'm picking that the FMR advertising bureau have covered themselves in glory once again.
This wouldn't be too bad, but as part of checking compliance of these machines, one of the methods is to measure the speed of the engine with a tachometer and to calculate the fan speed from the supplied gear ratios. It's not going to be a pretty sight if the calculation for a Defender fan shows it to be turning at 542rpm. Not pretty at all.
But wait!!
It get's more interesting.
On the same web page that provides the gear ratios, is a small note near the bottom that talks about the electric powered wind machines. A UD105E, of which there is a variant that is exported for use on 50 Hz systems, has a ratio of 2.47:1.
And guess what?
2000/(2.47x2.25) equals 360. Which would be correct according to the UoC figures. So I'm going to presume that in spite of what the Defender advertising says, the University of Canterbury figures are correct and that the model of upper gear used in the Defender is the export model UD105E.
Now this might all seem like nit picking at the expense of a company that is more interested in a glossy brochure than the accuracy of the figures in it, but there is a slightly more worrying side.
The Amarillo gear company are justifiably proud of their sturdy gears. So much so that they specify their mechanical rating for both the UD105 and the W85. And both of these units are used in the Amarillo frost fan which is rated at 125HP at the fan.
But the electric powered fans are a different kettle of fish. They are rated at either 100, 75 or 50hp at the fan. And as a result the mechanical rating of the gears can afford to be less.
So what would happen to a gear that is rated for a light load on a frost fan designed to run electrically when it is used in a diesel powered fan which runs at a heavier load? What is the subsequent load when the thrust of the fan is increased when a larger fan is put on the tower?
I'm sure all these trifling mechanical matters have been carefully considered by the manufacturer and that they have sought the advice of the parts suppliers in making sure that the device is safe for use. I mean, that would be the responsible thing wouldn't it?

Friday, 18 September 2009

Good news. Some testing data on the Defender fan has arrived

Well we finally have some information from the boffins at University of Canterbury. Specifically a K. Shaw and Dr John Pearse.
The testing report can be downloaded from here.
The first thing I would like to say is that is appears to be a quieter machine than the Amarillo. This would not be difficult of course, but credit where it is due, any improvement is not to be sneezed at.
The second thing of note is that it appears that FMR has been publishing incorrect data on the machine in its advertising. In the latest brochure (here (~500kB)) they state that "At full operating rpm the new Defender fan is producing less than 50dba(L10) at 300mt". I could be nit picky and poke the borax at the advertising wienie's understanding of basic physical measurements (that should be 50dBA (L10) and 300m (there is no 't' in the metres abbreviation, clowns)). However, an astute reader will note that I would seldom stoop to such a thing. Instead I will quietly point out that no test shows that the Defender ever produced less than 50dBA (L10) at 300m. In fact the testing states that the only test carried out at 300m produced 52.0dBA (L10). Almost twice as much as claimed. (on the basis that a 3dB increase is a doubling of noise energy).
There are several other tests at various distances, (100m and 200m) but only one at 300m.
The last point and the most interesting is that the claim of "less than 50dba(L10) at 300mt" was most likely derived from a predicted value for noise from the fan. Not measured.
More interesting still was the method of prediction. You see the 300m test wasn't done in frosty, inversion layer conditions. Instead they were done in 11 degrees centigrade and a cross-wind. There is a prediction method that allows for compensating for differing climatic conditions when measuring noise. This is the CONCAWE method (1MB) (there are infact several different methods).
Sadly this method does not allow for the presence of an inversion layer with it's associated noise refraction properties and worst of all it is not designed for the noise from frost fans. Instead it is designed to be applied to petrochemical installations. Now I would be happy to say that the prediction methods for frost fan noise using the CONCAWE method were valid, but that has never been demonstrated, and quite frankly when the testing presumes to predict that noise from a frost fan will be quieter when an inversion is in place on a calm frosty night, I have my doubts.
By the way, what frequency ranges were being considered in the noise report? I couldn't see any stated, yet it appears to be a big deal when doing the CONCAWE calculations. I suppose the frequencies most likely to be associated with a frost fan?
I'm sorry Dr Pearse, some testing to validate the CONCAWE model against the noise characteristics of a frost fan in frost conditions would be required. Otherwise any predicted values are assumptions, not conclusions.

Sunday, 6 September 2009

What they said in the Council Meeting on the 24th of August

Although it has already been reported that there was universal support for the proposed changes to the frost fan rules in the recent Council meeting, please find a selection of quotations from that meeting here;

Councillor Bowers;
“
I’m pleased that they’re called frost fans now, not wind machines, because in actual fact they’re being used for a lot of variety of things when there’s no frost.”

Pere Hawes;
“
The existing wind machines (or frost fans as we’re now calling them) are covered by existing use rights, that is, if they comply with the existing permitted activity standard, they can continue to operate in accordance with that permitted activity standard.”

Councillor Bunting;
“
Councillors, you will be aware that this is an attempt to put council on the front foot with this one, because it’s made it very difficult for Council staff members to achieve compliance, and this way any new frost fans will have to prove that they comply, rather than as it currently stands whereby members of public need to prove they don’t comply, which is a difficult, difficult thing for people to do."

Councillor Taylor;
"
That’s a concern that I’ve got one on the graph here that shows nearly a thousand already in place, and that is a concern regarding the existing ones which are of course the problem”

Councillor Jerram;
“
As you will note, I am a rural person and I am traditionally in favour of… ahhh I’m sympathetic to rural causes, but I support this motion on the grounds that this is not traditional rural noise, it is new rural noise. It’s something that we haven’t seen before. It’s not headers at night or weaned calves, or whatever noises that have always been accepted in this country, it’s something quite new, and it’s significantly worse than anything we’ve seen before.”
"Where these are used, it’s a need to grow grapes in areas which are either marginally environmentally correct, or right outside their natural environment. So I think it’s not reasonable to then, say to anyone who lives in the area, “oh and you’ve go to put up with this noise as well, we’ve moved into your area to grow a crop for which we have to significantly alter the environment”. So I’m supporting it on those grounds. Really Madam chair I think we should have done this a long time ago, and also for gas guns
”.

Councillor Bunting;
“
The industry has taken on board concerns and are starting to make moves to discuss it with the affected parties, discuss their individual issues, because quite a lot of them are quite subjective issues due to the climatic conditions that the situation of the buildings nearby to hills or with echo effect on hills and also cumulative effect of a number of machines. So industry did indicate at our last meeting that they were interested in discussing with individuals and I believe that some of those discussions have started.”

Councillor Bunting;
“
Can you say why we’ve referred to the 100m?”
Pere Hawes;
"
The 100 metres has been removed really on the basis that it didn’t relate to any noise management provisions at all. In fact the genesis of that standard was very unclear.”

Councillor Maher;
“
It’s great that we have actually got to this stage where we are able to deal with some of the rogues that there have been, as most of these machines have not affected people. Mostly good will has been used, and common sense has been used. Unfortunately it hasn’t in some cases and some of those people that have been aware of the usual rural rules have tried to hide behind the right to farm and the fact that this is a farming environment. What they’ve got to learn (and some of these people are not locals) is that there are standards that have been, over a long time, have been built up, and they’ve been built up on reasonableness and consideration for others and whatever industry you’re in, if you move away from those, Council will be required to legislate as in this particular case. And I as a rural person find it a real pity that this good will is actually being milked and probably abused by people without blatant consideration for others and I think that’s a great pity that Councillors have to go through this process and those few people have caused this and they’ve cause considerable hardship to a number of individuals too and it’s a great pity that we aren’t able to do something retrospectively but I think with the new regulations and once we do get our forensic stuff done, that we can actually quantify and qualify these things more accurately than we’ve been able to do in the past. So overall I think this is unfortunate but it will have a positive effect on people living in the rural environment.”
“I’ve been rural environment for a long time myself, but these things ,when they start springing up near me, I actually start to question, and actually, aren’t tolerances actually stretched when it comes to these machines being installed incorrectly and abusing the good will that there has been.
”
Councillor Bunting;
“Thank you, the deputy chair, I certainly would echo your sentiments and that has been motivation for driving this item along. As you know it has been driven fairly rapidly, and I think the Industry does have a belief now that they do need to discuss with the affected people, the most affected people, what their concerns are and perhaps even experience it themselves for a little while.”

Saturday, 22 August 2009

Suddenly its gone quiet. Too quiet.

There is a possibility, that I was mistaken. Yes, I know hard to believe.
In this post two days ago, I claimed that there had been no monitoring of frost fans by the Council except for an abortive (and embarrassing) debacle about two years ago and one earlier this year for which the results had not even been published.
A small bird has told me that the results HAVE now been published. I have yet to have a copy hand delivered, but I understand there is something in there that will come as a bit of a shock.

You might want to sit down.

Both fans measured were found to be non-compliant with the District plan.
I know, I know, it came as a shock to me too.
Surely the growers were taking great pains to make sure they were protecting the environment and their neighbours?
Surely the frost fan installers (I presume that this was FMR as I understand that they are Amarillo fans) were professional in making sure their clients weren't exposed to breaching the District rules?

Wait! I know what's happened! By some amazing fluke they have selected the only two non-compliant frost fans in the district. Curse their bad luck!

Apparently there's still more (trust me, I'm still reeling). Both fans apparently exhibited special audible characteristics (tonality and impulsiveness), which make them particularly annoying.

Wow! That's not the best is it?
I suppose it could have been worse, there could have been someone (perhaps even a family) living next door who had been there for many years before the grapes were planted and the fans put in. This family could in theory be 100m away from these fans. Boy, it's lucky that's not the case and that they didn't measure the noise outside their house!

Hang on. There IS a family living next door who had these fans planted 100m away from them?
And the noise was measured at 74dBA L10?
Wait a minute, that can't be right. That level of noise is the same as having an un-silenced wood chipper running outside your bedroom. Surely they would complain? Oh they did? Years ago? and the Council wrung their hands for how long?

So now they're going to do something right?

Right?

Thursday, 20 August 2009

Come in Spinner!

In the recent article in the Marlborough Express on the upcoming environmental policy committee meeting on the 24th (especially regards frost fans), there were several comments which caught my eye.
Firstly Stuart Smith. Describing the proposed changes as an "ill thought quick fix" seems a bit rich considering the extraordinarily long time its taken and the endless debate that has been occurring around the issue. Then claiming that the rural sector is being "foot tripped every step of the way" is pitiful. How many resource consents have EVER been turned down on an application to install a frost fan? NONE. If that is 'foot tripping', I'd hate to see them get assistance! As for any implication from both him and Jill Bunting that there has been any form of discussions between affected residents, Council and the NZ Wine growers, that is pure fiction. The only interaction has been filing of submissions, court appearances and curt words over the fence. There's been no indication of a desire to mediate or negotiate, probably on account of the separation of significant foreign (not local) ownership of the vineyards themselves. Why would the owner care? They don't live there. Send in the lawyers.

Secondly Jill Bunting. "This is a fair outcome for everyone". What on earth? Yeah, all those people with their houses 100m away from a mechanical noise maker are thanking you now Jill. All those people whose houses are currently surrounded by fans are probably worshiping an effigy of you as I write. "Monitoring of existing machines was taking place". Eh? Where? Do you mean the abortive efforts by Neil Morris a couple of years ago that were so flawed that a separate report had to be written to explain how a 5dB penalty should be subtracted not added? perhaps you mean the testing earlier this year down the Waihopai valley? Good start, only took four years of complaints to action and then we have still not seen the results. THERE IS NO MONITORING. That's why Mr Maassen has said that there needs to be some!
I see Malcolm and Paul got a couple of digs in. But really they're stuffed aren't they? Since their problems can't be fixed by this change, all they can do is hope that things improve for some other soul in an unaffected part of Marlborough (if it exists).

Wednesday, 19 August 2009

Definitions

Plan: Have the will and intention to carry out some action; "The Marlborough District Council plan to protect the health of residents".

Integrity: Moral soundness; "The Marlborough District Council have acted with integrity when faced with difficult decisions"

Duty: Work that you are obliged to perform for moral or legal reasons; "The Marlborough District Council have a duty to protect the environment."

Responsibility: The trait of being answerable to someone for something or being responsible for one's conduct; "The Marlborough District Council are fulfilling their responsibilities under the RMA and Health Acts"

Rudderless: Lacking in direction, control, or coherence; "The Marlborough District Council are rudderless in the face of providing sound policy "

Inept: Displaying a lack of judgment, sense, or reason; "The Marlborough District Council have been inept in their handling of frost fan resource consents"

Hypocrisy: A show or expression of feelings or beliefs one does not actually hold or possess; "The Marlborough District Council have displayed hypocrisy in dealing with the human impact of frost fan noise"

Clueless: Totally uninformed about what is going on or not having even a clue from which to infer what is occurring; "The Marlborough District Council have been clueless in the pursuit of suitable monitoring methodologies for frost fans"

Indifferent: Showing no care or concern in attitude or action; "The Marlborough District Council are indifferent to the health of the residents"

Definitions of words and examples of their use in everyday language. Some examples are more believable than others.

Wednesday, 29 April 2009

Measurement of frost fan rotation for checking compliance.

Thanks Jack for having me back on the blog. Hopefully I’ve got something here suitable for your readers on both sides of the fence to use to help make sure that every one is playing by the rules.

In October last year I outlined different potential methods for measuring the speed of rotation of frost fans. This was in a follow up to my post on what needs to be measured to ensure compliance, where I backed a system of measuring the speed of rotation to confirm compliance with an accepted level of noise (established by expert testing as part of the commissioning process for a model of fan).

While I outlined several different techniques in theory, I did not have a workable solution for any. I now do.

I have prepared a paper on how to measure the speed of a frost fan and by doing so establishing its compliance with an established noise level.

This method uses a video camera to capture the fans motion and software to measure the rotation. This is a technique that can be carried out relatively easily, at good distances (I have measured fans at over 830 metres distance) and with a high degree of accuracy (the paper describes two additional different measurements that were carried out in order to confirm the rotation of a fan to verify accuracy).

This described method can be carried out at night time with the application of sufficient illumination and provides a record of evidence of whether the activity is compliant or not.

I have measured approximately a dozen fans thus far and have found the technique becomes easier after a bit of practice.

I have published this under the GNU Free Document Licence which gives people the right to freely copy and distribute it with the proviso that is cannot be modified without ensuring that the free nature of the document continues (at least that’s what the legal fraternity seem to believe). In other words, it’s free to use and if you want to use it as the basis for future work on the topic, this must be free also.

 If there are questions on the technique, feel free to leave them in the comments section.

The paper can be downloaded from here. (1.7MB download)

Monday, 9 March 2009

How ideal are smudge pots for frost protection?

I have deliberately chosen smudge pots (not to be confused with return stack burners) as the first frost protection method to be evaluated as they have some aspects of operation that are controversial (like being so bad that even local body Councils have banned their use).
How do they feature?

The Grower:
  • It should be cost effective to install and run.                                  Very Cost effective
  • It must be reliable.                                                                       The mechanism is simple, so failures are unlikely.
  • It must protect the crop from frost.                                               Effective protection.
  • It should not be labour intensive.                                                  There is a medium to high requirement for attention during operation
  • It must be safe to operate.                                                           Probably about medium
The Crop:
  • It must not affect the normal growth / development of the plant.   No problem
  • It should not introduce any foreign contaminants.                          Probably a low to medium risk here.
  • The quality of the fruit should be unchanged.                                Probably low to medium again
The Environment:
  • It should not deplete a natural resource.                                      It burnt oxygen, but this hasn't been identified yet as a resource depletion issue.
  • It should not make any physical impact other than on the crop.    The physical impact was high with huge palls of smoke covering large areas and soot accompanying it.
  • It should not introduce any pollutant to the environment.             Very high with considerable pollutants released into the atmosphere.
The Neighbour:
  • Its operation mustn’t affect their health.                                   Medium risk with smoke pollution exposure
  • Its operation shouldn’t degrade their property values.                Property values relatively unaffected unless it was during a frost season (so low)
  • It shouldn’t degrade their enjoyment of their own property.        During times of use, enjoyment would drop considerably.
What can we read from this?
Well with features that were important to the grower and relatively benign affect on the crop, the technique was popular in the day. In spite of a significant impact on the environment and neighbours. However as consciousness was raised to the health risks and pollution impact, regulations were enacted to limit, prevent or alter the activity.Parallels can be drawn with frost fans in the sense that what little regulations are in place are not well structured or not followed and this has allowed the wild west mentality to take hold. Now as the impact of the devices has begun to be felt by more and more people, their use is being viewed less favorably.

Sunday, 19 October 2008

New Amarillo Blades

Recently spotted undergoing trials in Marlborough is a new style blade fitted to an Amarillo frost fan.

This sucker is a whopper. Estimates from photo comparisons put it at approximately 6.4 metres long. This would be the longest blade diameter currently known in NZ (for a frost fan).

Astute observers will note that the design has at least made some attempt to shape the blades in an aerodynamic fashion, although devotees will realise that it takes more than shaping some curves into the end of your metal to produce an efficient design.

The site of the blade is one subject to a recent Environment Court ruling that imposed a condition of consent that the cumulative noise from both machines should be no more than 55dBA L10 at 300 metres. For those so inclined, take a drive down Paynters road in Fairhall (just outside Blenheim). Or you could view the location here on Google Maps.

For those that need reminding the picture below is the standard Amarillo blade shape. I know they look crude, but......  OK, they have no redeeming features other than being crude.


On another point, I know that I've poked the borax at the Department of Labour (OSH) in the past, but I'm glad to see their message getting through to operators of cherry pickers like the guy in the top photograph. For those who want to know, the accepted safe practice is to be wearing a safety harness when working in a cherry picker. That may be it draped on the rail beside him. Perhaps he took it off so he could reach out of the platform as he appears to be doing.  If anyone cares, please leave a comment on this post and I can try to find out who 'safety first' guy is.

Thursday, 16 October 2008

What is the Councils involvement with frost fans?

So why is the Council copping so much grief over the issue of frost fans? 

The information below is taken from the Marlborough District Councils web site that outlines their role from a regulatory standpoint. 

The Marlborough District Council is responsible for administering a wide range of regulatory functions, powers and duties conferred by Acts of Parliament.

The council's Regulatory Department administers more than 40 different statutes and regulations.

These statutes include the Resource Management Act (RMA), the Building Act and the Health Act. Generally these involve the council authorising certain activities, e.g. marine farming, and building construction. Having approved consents for such activities, the council monitors them to ensure on-going compliance.

The council's role also includes the investigation of complaints.

The council is required to develop plans that set out policies and rules for the sustainable management of Marlborough's natural and physical resources.

In short, they are responsible for ensuring that the laws of the land that are outlined in Acts of Parliament are observed on a local scale with respect the management of the environment and managing the safety and health of the population. 

They do this via a District Plan. This takes the relevant laws and ensures that a framework for following them is maintained at a local level. 

For the purposes of frost fans, the Council are bound to ensure the following in accordance with the Resource Management Act (these are not the full sections, just some juicy bits). 

Section 3:
Meaning of effect 
In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires, the term effect includes— 
(d) Any cumulative effect which arises over time or in combination with other effects 

Section 16: 
Duty to avoid unreasonable noise 
(1) Every occupier of land (including any premises and any coastal marine area), and every person carrying out an activity in, on, or under a water body or the coastal marine area, shall adopt the best practicable option to ensure that the emission of noise from that land or water does not exceed a reasonable level. 

Section 17:
Duty to avoid, remedy, or mitigate adverse effects 
(1) Every person has a duty to avoid, remedy, or mitigate any adverse effect on the environment arising from an activity carried on by or on behalf of that person.

Section 326: 
Meaning of excessive noise 
(1)  In this Act, the term excessive noise means any noise that is under human control and of such a nature as to unreasonably interfere with the peace, comfort, and convenience of any person (other than a person in or at the place from which the noise is being emitted) 

Likewise, the Health Act; 

Section 29 
Nuisances defined for purposes of this Act 
Without limiting the meaning of the term "nuisance'', a nuisance shall be deemed to be created in any of the following cases, that is to say:  
(ka) Where any noise or vibration occurs in or is emitted from any building, premises, or land to a degree that is likely to be injurious to health:] 

Section 30:
Penalties for permitting or causing nuisances-
(1). Every person by whose act, default, or sufferance a nuisance arises or continues, whether that person is or is not the owner or occupier of the premises in respect of which the nuisance exists, commits an offence against this Act. 

So the Council Set the Rules in the District Plan.
For frost fans they have a set of rules under section 1.4.3.2.

So why is there a problem?

Well, if a developer wants to install a frost fan that exceeds any of those rules, they have to apply for and be granted a resource consent to do so.

Problem here is that there is a history that suggests a failure to comprehend the implications of some of the applications and in some cases a failure to understand basic physics.
In short frost fan resource consent applications typically get approved. 
Aside from the issue of incompetence in dealing with the resource consent process, there is a fundamental problem that has plagued the Council for years.

They can’t / don’t / won’t enforce their frost fan rules or consents with regard noise.

It really is that simple. If a neighbour complains that a frost fan is exceeding the noise limit in the District Plan, the Council have no mechanism in place for ensuring compliance.

None. 

So this is why the Council are copping grief.
Annoyed neighbours of frost fans that are kept awake see no possibility for a resolution to their problem.
The Council have applied a policy that they cannot measure compliance of and cannot monitor.

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

Orchard Wrong

Something just twigged today. I'm a bit slow I suppose.

You see when I described the noise of the Orchard Rite fans from Royce McKeans property up the Wairau Valley (and let's not forget the Hurunui). I referenced a report from Hegley Acoustics.
This report was completed in January 2006 from testing carried out in 2005.
In it Nevil Hegley records the noise levels of the model 2500D and 3000D Orchard Rite fans at 100 metres and calculates the levels that will be present at 300 metres.

They are as follows (all are L10 values by the way);

Wind Machine      @100m  @300m
2500D at 1850rpm  69dBA 59dBA
at 2000rpm 71dBA 61dBA
at 2270rpm 73dBA 63dBA
3000D at 1850rpm 64dBA 54dBA
at 2000rpm 67dBA 57dBA
at 2100rpm 67dBA 57dBA
at 2270rpm 69dBA 59dBA

Throughout the report Mr Hegley describes the noise as 'tonal' in other words it is exhibiting 'Special Audible Characteristics'. Now these characteristics mean that in accordance with the requirements of NZS 6801: 1991 (the noise standard almost universally used by District Councils) noise that exhibts them must include a 5dB penalty because of the intrusive nature of the noise. (in fairness to Orchard Rite, acoustics experts appear to universally agree that all frost fans running at their efficient speeds exhibit these characteristics).

This means that of all these readings only ONE actually meets the requirements of the Marlborough District Councils noise limit of 55dBA L10 at 300 metres (this figure includes the 5dB penalty for special audible characteristics).
So I presume that if Mr McKean is operating one of these models of fan (and he is certainly operating the 3000D according to the resource consent in Hurunui) then he can only operate them at 1850rpm in order to be compliant with the District Plan (in Marlborough).
Unless he has a resource consent to exceed the limit of course. 

So how do the council ensure compliance with the District Plan? I believe we've established that they don't do any measuring at all. Not before installation, and not after. 
Mr Maclean seems to think it can be done and done easily.
And yet they've done nothing.
     Nothing.
          Nothing.
              Nothing.
At least they've done it consistently.

Meanwhile no doubt Mr Mckean is lawfully operating his fans at the lowest setting to avoid making too much noise.

Monday, 13 October 2008

Councils duty to monitor and gather information

Section 35 of the Resource management act sets out the duties of District Councils to gather information, monitor and keep records.
It is this section that provides the requirement to monitor compliance with resource consents and to make that information available for the purposes of transparancy.
It has been established that the Marlborough District Council have been unable to monitor their frost fan requirements per the Plan and their imposed conditions of consent. However, it is useful to read the full section to be aware of the legal requirements and to know your rights when requesting infromation. Remember, they work for you, not the other way around.

35 Duty to gather information, monitor, and keep records

(1) Every local authority shall gather such information, and under ­ take or commission such research, as is necessary to carry out effectively its functions under this Act.

(2) Every local authority shall monitor—
(a) The state of the whole or any part of the environment of its region or district to the extent that is appropriate to enable the local authority to effectively carry out its
functions under this Act; and
(b) the efficiency and effectiveness of policies, rules, or other methods in its policy statement or its plan; and
(c) The exercise of any functions, powers, or duties delegated or transferred by it; and
(d) The exercise of the resource consents that have effect in its region or district, as the case may be; and
(e) in the case of a regional council, the exercise of a recog­nised customary activity in its region, including any controls imposed under Schedule 12 on that activity ,— and take appropriate action (having regard to the methods available to it under this Act) where this is shown to be necessary .
(2A) Every local authority must, at intervals of not more than 5 years, compile and make available to the public a review of the results of its monitoring under subsection (2)(b) .

(3) Every local authority shall keep reasonably available at its principal office, information which is relevant to the administration of policy statements and plans, the monitoring of resource consents, and current issues relating to the environment of the area, to enable the public—
(a) To be better informed of their duties and of the functions, powers, and duties of the local authority; and
(b) T o participate effectively under this Act.

(4) Every local authority shall keep reasonably available at each of the offices in its region or district such of the information referred to in subsection (3) as relates to that part of the region or district.

(5) The information to be kept by a local authority under subsection (3) shall include—
(a) Copies of its operative and any proposed policy statements and plans including all requirements for designations and heritage orders, and all operative and proposed changes to those policy statements and plans; and
(aa) copies of all material incorporated by reference in any plan or proposed plan under Part 3 of Schedule 1; and
(b) All its decisions relating to submissions on any proposed policy statements and plans which have not yet become operative; and
(c) In the case of a territorial authority, copies of every operative and proposed regional policy statement and regional plan for the region of which its district forms
part; and
(d) In the case of a regional council, copies of every operative and proposed district plan for every territorial authority in its region; and
(e) In the case of a regional council, a copy of every Order in Council served on it under section 154(a) ; and
(f) Copies of any national policy statement or New Zealand coastal policy statement; and
(g) records of all applications for resource consents received by it; and
(ga) records of all decisions under any of sections 93 to 94C ; and
(gb) records of all resource consents granted within the local authority’ s region or district; and
(gc) records of the transfer of any resource consent; and
(h) Records of all extensions of time periods and waivers granted by it under section 37 in relation to applications under section 10 (which relates to existing uses), section
125 (which relates to lapsing of consents), and section 184 (which relates to lapsing of designations) during the preceding 5 years; and
(i) A summary of all written complaints received by it during the preceding 5 years concerning alleged breaches of the Act or a plan, and information on how it dealt
with each such complaint; and
(j) Records of natural hazards to the extent that the local authority considers appropriate for the effective discharge of its functions; and
(ja) In the case of a territorial authority, the location and area of all esplanade reserves, esplanade strips, and access strips in the district; and
(jb) in the case of a regional council, records of every customary rights order relating to its region; and
(k) Any other information gathered under subsections (1) and (2).